If you are one of the many people who has referred to a nonprofit organization as a "tax-exempt group," this article is for you. This common misconception is rooted in a misunderstanding concerning the meaningful differences between a nonprofit and tax-exempt status.
Do not feel alone if you have made this mistake, as it is common even for those in the nonprofit sector to use these two terms interchangeably. This article will provide an in-depth look at these two separate and distinct concepts, helping you better understand how to incorporate a nonprofit and navigate these legal complexities.
Right off the bat, it is helpful to understand that nonprofit status is a concept based on state law. The term 'nonprofit' itself typically refers to organizations created to benefit and/or serve the public interest in some meaningful capacity, as opposed to existing to provide financial benefits to a person, corporation, or other entity.
Effectively, nonprofits will not distribute profits to shareholders, and any organizational surplus remains with the organization to be used for the organization's expressed purposes. Since nonprofit status is given by states, each state will have its own nonprofit corporation laws that provide guidelines, regulations, and similar information on how nonprofits in the state are to be organized and structured.
The ideal way to structure a nonprofit organization will depend on the organization's goals and what the state allows. Generally speaking, nonprofits can be set up in the following legal formats:
For more precise information and guidelines, visit your state's Secretary of State website for exact information on the allowed legal formats and business structures for a nonprofit organization.
Also, be advised that you may incorporate a nonprofit organization in a state outside of your state of residence. For some states, nonprofit corporations in particular can be formed by filing articles of incorporation or a certificate of formation, which are the same forms used to create a for-profit corporation.
While nonprofit status is a concept based on state law, tax-exempt status is a federal concept that relates to federal income tax exemption. Since tax-exempt status is tied to federal taxation, you will be unsurprised to know that the IRS is the federal authority tasked with granting tax-exempt status.
Organizations seeking exemption from federal income tax must do so based on relevant sections of the Internal Revenue Code. If you have ever heard the term '501(c)(3) nonprofit organization' or something similar, the term '501(c)(3)' merely refers to a section of the Code that allows the nonprofit organization to be exempt from paying federal income tax.
It is important to clarify here that tax-exempt status does not mean exemption from paying all taxes. As stated, tax-exempt status refers only to federal corporate income tax exemption. Even then, the federal exemption applies solely to income that was generated from activities that are substantially related to the organization's purposes that were granted federal tax exemption.
Any income that is unrelated to the nonprofit's tax-exempt purposes will still be subjected to federal income tax. Nonprofits that meet federal tax-exemption standards can typically use this exemption to also be exempt from state corporate income tax, but exceptions can apply.
Still, nonprofits will still be expected to pay the following taxes:
With these basic facts in mind, it is time to take a closer look at what will qualify a nonprofit for tax exemption.
Tax-exempt status is not applied automatically, as nonprofits must apply to the IRS for tax-exempt status. There are 29 types of nonprofit organizations within the IRS tax code, all of which have different requirements to meet; for example, 501(c)(23) status applies to veteran-owned organizations and 501(k) status applies to childcare organizations.
501(c)(3) status is perhaps the most common way for a nonprofit to obtain federal tax exemption. This section of the Internal Revenue Code pertains to tax-exempt status for charitable nonprofits.
For charitable nonprofits applying for 501(c)(3) tax-exempt status, three tests must be met. First, the tax-exempt nonprofit must be organized for a lawful purpose. For the purposes of 501(c)(3) status, a lawful purpose exists for nonprofits in the following categories:
If this test is passed, the organization must then also meet a political test by stating in the organization's organizing documents that the organization will not spend on political purposes or involve themselves in a political campaign on behalf of a candidate. If an organization wishes to engage in such activity, then a 501(c) exemption may still be obtained, but not a 501(c)(3) exemption.
This political test is meant to ensure that charitable organizations receiving federal income tax exemption remain politically neutral. A certificate of incorporation is often used to express the purpose of an organization, which can make this document especially valuable for meeting this second test.
Finally, the charitable nonprofit must meet an asset test within the nonprofit charter. The charter should state that the distribution of assets or income to individuals, except for the purposes of providing fair compensation for the individual's services, is prohibited. Additionally, the organization should clearly state within the charter that the nonprofit is not to be used for the personal gain of the following people:
If these tests are met, then the nonprofit will have achieved the rare benefit of receiving favorable tax treatment as well as tax deductions for donors. Only 501(c)(3) organizations enjoy both of these benefits in tandem.
There are many other paths toward tax-exempt status, each having their own requirements for the organization to fulfill.
For organizations that apply for tax-exempt status and obtain it, the exemption is not a lifetime award, naturally. To maintain tax-exempt status, the organization will need to submit annual information filings every year, just as for-profit corporations are typically required to do. There are some exceptions to this general rule, such as churches and some political organizations.
For most nonprofits, however, failing to submit the annual filing can lead to fines, penalties, and even the loss of the organization's tax-exempt status. In short, tax-exemption is something that can go south very quickly if the organization does not provide the required annual updates.
The most obvious benefits of tax-exempt status are the federal income tax and state income tax perks, but there are other benefits to consider as well; for example, 501(c)(3) nonprofits enjoy the unique benefit of providing donors with the ability to deduct their donations on their taxes. Similarly, some grants and public allocations are only offered to 501(c)(3) organizations. Depending on the nonprofit's mission, these grants can make a world of difference for the expressed purpose of the organization.
Another real-world, significant benefit of tax-exempt status is the public's perception of the organization. Obtaining tax-exempt status as a nonprofit gives the organization a tangible boost in its public profile and credibility in the public eye. Any nonprofit that is officially recognized by the IRS gives the organization an added sense of legitimacy, which helps gain public trust.
Depending on the state, a tax-exempt nonprofit may even be exempt from certain state taxes as well, such as sales and property taxes. Do your due diligence to determine whether these benefits may extend to the state in which you have chosen to set up your nonprofit.
After all this discussion about the difference between nonprofits and tax exemption, you may be left wondering what the best path toward obtaining the benefits of tax exemption is. Here is a general guideline, even if it is by no means a "one size fits all" template.
LegalNature can help you with all of your legal form needs. Let us help you get started today. Click here to create your business formation documents now.
Contact us here.